Jingles: The Solution to Voluntary Medical Male Circumcision?

| posted in: Blog, CommsConsult Africa | 3

So I have a daily routine which involves using my twenty minute drive to work to collect my thoughts and finalise my plan for the day. It is very simple really, I just turn my radio on, focus on the morning traffic while I let my thoughts wonder on the tasks ahead. Usually I have the cool sounds of the ZiFM breakfast show to keep me company and offer a laugh from time to time, as all good morning radio shows should. When I emerge at our beautiful offices I find myself humming a tune and embracing the day ahead. Like I said…really simple.

However, for the past few days I have emerged from my vehicle singing a jingle about… drumroll please… voluntary medical male circumcision (VMMC)! I know right, medical male circumcision has made its way onto our airwaves and I am a victim of the catchy tune. Usually, the jingles stuck in my head are about super fast ADSL or some mobile phone company’s ‘super saving’ promotion, but not today! I am proudly humming about getting circumcised (not me in particular but I am inadvertently encouraging men to go out and get circumcised…as this is the cool thing to do!).

Now being part of a strategic communication outfit, it shouldn’t surprise me what a powerful tool the radio can be for spreading development messages; however, I find myself still being pleasantly surprised. The short but effective jingle has me wondering how many of my male friends have opted to get circumcised, what informed their decision and most importantly I am curious about the impact of this campaign. I for one am surely not part of the target audience but I find myself strangely affected.

jah-prayzah-550
Popular Zimbabwean musician Jah Prayzah, one of the PSI Zimbabwe campaign ambassadors. Image: New Zimbabwe

I find myself thinking about impact evaluations that are looking into the effectiveness of particular campaigns to encourage grown men to engage in what I can only imagine is a very uncomfortable (and I am downplaying it here… the real word is probably excruciating) procedure.

PSI Zimbabwe is leading this campaign to promote voluntary medical male circumcision in Zimbabwe. They have launched a series of campaigns with popular musician Winky D as the initial front man of the campaign. The campaign began in 2011 and has grown to include numerous other popular artists on the local music scene. I couldn’t say how effective the campaign has been in actually translating hooking jingles into action but I am sure that it has caught the attention of a few people, it definitely has mine. The campaign also includes a growing Facebook page with 803 followers (as of 6 November 2013). The page is regularly updated and interactive, which is a real plus in terms of engagement.

The campaign has been criticised for sending mixed messages that encourage young people to get circumcised and abandon other forms of contraception. However, after a very quick browse of their Facebook page I was impressed to see comments from PSI encouraging both circumcision and the use of condoms.

We usually train that radio is still the most effective and efficient way to get messages to a broader audience in Africa. In Zimbabwe there is a 30-35 % radio penetration making this the most powerful medium for mass communication (television has 20-30%[i] penetration and newspapers are even less). ZiFM which is the newest radio station on the block (the only privately owned radio station in Zimbabwe) definitely has increased the reach of radio to some of our less serviced areas such as Mutorashanga.

So now that they have the correct medium, convincing champions (Jah Prayzah’s version really caught my attention) and a few catchy jingles, I really wonder what the impact of this campaign has been. I am off in search of some stats, who knows, maybe I can convince someone from PSI to give me some compelling information to assess the impact of the campaign on actually increasing VMMC.

For now, I will continue singing “pinda musmart, enda unochecheudzwa…” (loosely translated, join the smart crowd and go get circumcised)… I may just start asking my male friends to answer some challenging questions if they haven’t joined the smart crowd!



[i] According to the Africa Media Barometer 2010

3 Responses

  1. Mark Lyndon

    Getting circumcised is not a cool thing to do. It certainly doesn’t seem to help against HIV. Your smart friends will stay intact.

    From a USAID report:
    “There appears no clear pattern of association between male circumcision and HIV prevalence—in 8 of 18 countries with data, HIV prevalence is lower among circumcised men, while in the remaining 10 countries it is higher.”
    http://www.measuredhs.com/pubs/pdf/CR22/CR22.pdf

    It seems highly unrealistic to expect that there will be no risk compensation. The South African National Communication Survey on HIV/AIDS, 2009 found that 15% of adults across age groups “believe that circumcised men do not need to use condoms”.
    http://www.info.gov.za/issues/hiv/survey_2009.htm

    It is unclear if circumcised men are more likely to infect women. The only ever randomized controlled trial into male-to-female transmission showed a 54% higher rate in the group where the men had been circumcised:
    http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(09)60998-3/abstract

    ABC (Abstinence, Being faithful, and especially Condoms) is the way forward. Promoting genital surgery seems likely to cost African lives rather than save them.

    Europeans don’t circumcise, South Americans don’t circumcise, Australians and New Zealanders used to circumcise but stopped, and less than half of North Americans circumcise. Why should Africans circumcise?

    Recent news from Botswana
    “There is an upsurge of cases of people who got infected with HIV following circumcision.”
    http://www.gabzfm.com/circumcised-men-still-run-risk-hiv-infection

  2. Thanks for your comment Mark. Firstly, just to clarify, when I initially
    wrote this post it was not supposed to advocate for or against male
    circumcision. I realise that the general tone may have suggested that I am
    in favour of it but what really fascinated me was the strategic
    communication intervention employed by PSI to promote VMMC. The campaign has
    gotten significant airplay and I was very curious to know whether increased
    airplay, popular musicians and catchy tunes where a viable and effective
    method in development interventions.

    The team here has done some previous research into the use of radio for development communication across Africa:
    http://www.researchtoaction.org/2012/03/radio-convergence-and-development-in-africa-networking-for-research-impact/ and communicating beyond the academic community: http://www.researchtoaction.org/2012/03/communicating-beyond-the-academic-community/

    It is tragic to hear that the push towards VMMC has resulted in some people
    believing that male circumcision exempts them from condom use. I think this
    was the main criticism of earlier campaigns, which seemed to suggest that
    male circumcision was the end all solution to HIV prevalence. This is just
    not true and as I mentioned earlier, I was impressed that the PSI Facebook
    page was advocating for both male circumcision and condom use.

    The increase in VMMC in Africa was driven by a number of RCTs across the
    continent; however, I am not an expert in this area and cannot say whether
    or not the current evidence is conclusive. However, what I can say is that
    any campaign that gets people engaged and talking about sexual health and
    the options available is at least worth some consideration as we all work
    towards the reduction of HIV prevalence across Africa. After having spoken
    to those who have taken the big step and those who are vehemently opposed,
    the arguments for both sides are numerous. I guess what I really wanted to
    know was are catchy jingles enough to affect behaviour or are people seeking
    other evidence to support their decisions (I am guessing the latter is true
    as some reports suggest that the impact of these campaigns has not been as
    fruitful as was initially hoped for).

  3. Tinashe Chimbidzikai

    Let me refer Mark to this factsheet about VMMC. http://www.avac.org/ht/a/GetDocumentAction/i/42517

Leave a Reply to Mark Lyndon

Click here to cancel reply.